
Info Commissioner and privacy groups up anti-campaign following report
By Tony Hallett
Published: 30 July 2004 16:20 BST
The Information Commissioner and privacy campaigners have added their voices to a UK Home Affairs select committee criticising plans for the use of ID cards.
Though the report was published today, yesterday the Guardian newspaper revealed leaked details - and the wider response has been negative.
Information Commissioner Richard Thomas has expressed his concerns over government plans in the recent past and today said in a statement that "the current proposals are far wider than necessary to implement a simple identity scheme".
He added that "many problems need addressing" and emphasised that the draft bill, as it stands now, is "not just about an ID card but an extensive national identity register and the creation of an extensive national identity registration number".
Thomas also holds concerns about why the government thinks it needs such an approach and which other bodies will be privy to information held.
Meanwhile, the Foundation for Information Policy Research, a long-time critic of government policy on information privacy, was clear in its response to the select committee report.
"The committee has raised a whole series of very grave concerns about the scheme. ID cards won't tackle terrorism, won't cut fraud and won't reduce crime. The government's plans are an expensive and dangerous folly," said FIPR director Ian Brown in a statement.
The FIPR warning ended with calls for a rethink by the Home Secretary and also touched on a subject that may make ideological arguments pointless - that such an IT project simply cannot be made to work.
Be a subject matter expert in the rationalisation of applications, gained through experience of shaping and delivering projects of this type. All ...
Please note: You MUST be eligible to work in the United Kingdom, and if successfully employed, you be subject to background checks which involve: ...
Please note: You MUST be eligible to work in the United Kingdom, and if successfully employed, you be subject to background checks which involve: ...
CIO50 2008
The silicon.com CIO50 2008 profiles the most influential and innovative tech chiefs in the UK across all industries and organisation size, from the biggest FTSE100 companies to high growth dot-com start ups and the public sector. The list was voted on by the UK CIO community and a panel of experts. Find out more in our latest special report.
July 10th: Just MASH Marketing: The Customer Reference Mashup
TechNet Webcast: How Microsoft Does IT: Management and Operations in Windows Server...
Mashing it up with Support: Automate, Coordinate and Collaborate with the Incident...
Ensure Virtualization is Meeting Your Needs--Read this New White Paper
Stories from the web...
Copyright ©1995-2008 CNET Networks, Inc. All rights reserved. Top of page
silicon.com Dear silicon.com: Tech teacher shortage, Kangaroo and phones on planes Reader Comments of the Week
Mike Barrett From CIO to consultant: Project manager or salesman? Hard lessons from the coalface…