
We must demand more from politicians
By silicon.com
Published: 20 September 2006 14:25 GMT
Europe's head of data protection - the EDPS - hit out this week at claims civil liberties advocates have been hampering anti-terror laws, adding that no good law can be passed without including some measures designed to keep citizens' data safe.
It's a debate that recurs over and over again whenever such laws are on the table - remember the European data retention directive and Ripa? Privacy advocates campaigned against both, labelling them a heavy-handed approach without due respect of the individual's rights.
Politicians in turn say there are bound to be instances where individuals must give up rights for the greater good; occasionally couching their retorts in language that would have you believe only woolly headed hippy throwbacks are genuinely concerned about such matters.
It's easy to use such throwaway remarks: after all, what civil libertarian won't come off worse when he's accused of impeding a government crusade to halt terrorism? And dismissing the civil liberties issues gives governments a little grease to get controversial legislation through parliament without having to work out those tricky privacy kinks.
As political climates change of course legislation must change with it - but there is no excuse for not writing data protection into the heart of laws, especially one such as the European data retention directive where such safeguards are so clearly needed.
Such laws are often rushed through in response to world events, when the desire to do something - anything - to counter new threats looms large in politicians' minds. Of course, when such threats recede, the legislation is not repealed with equal alacrity.
And that is why such legislation cannot be handled carefully enough. Tramping over individual freedoms and liberties is the behaviour of terrorists - it should not be what we expect from our government.
Well said, good article. Its about time we started...
Mr I like my freedom
It is a real sign that the issue is far from resol...
Daintree Peters
Senior Civil Structural Engineers - London & Sussex - ? pa + benefits We are actively looking for an experienced Civil Structural Engineer to join ...
Ensure that any information received, from External sources, on viruses detected, is passed to the Service Provider for action. You will be ...
You must also have experience with Information Security and Business Continuity and other relevant legislation. ICT Security Specialist/Information ...
Agenda Setters 2009
Welcome to the ninth annual Agenda Setters poll – silicon.com's list of the top 50 most influential individuals in the technology and IT industries, from techies and CIOs to entrepreneurs and business leaders. Find out more in our latest special report.
Power Solutions Article: High-Availability Virtualization with Dell EqualLogic Arrays...
Power Solutions Article:Â Power Solutions Article: Getting Started with Microsoft...
Customer Case Study:Â A L Filters
Solution Brief: Dell Equalogic PS Series Can Offer Robust, High-Availability Infrastructure...
Stories from the web...
Copyright © 2008 CBS Interactive Limited. All rights reserved. Top of page
Naked CIO Naked CIO: Social networks are useless for finding a job 'Quantity over quality' approach poisoning professional networks
Peter Cochrane Peter Cochrane's Blog: Uneconomics We must move away from short-termism to prevent next economic crisis