
Game over for McKinnon?
By Colin Barker
Published: 3 April 2007 15:56 BST
Gary McKinnon, the man accused of hacking into the computer systems of Nasa and other US governmental organisations, has lost his appeal against extradition to the US. But, according to his lawyers, the judges in the appeal court "definitely left the door open" for a further appeal to the House of Lords.
The Court of Appeal took a dim view of the alleged coercion applied to McKinnon, saying it "viewed with a degree of distaste the way in which the American authorities are alleged to have approached the plea bargain negotiations" with McKinnon.
McKinnon's hopes now rest on whether the House of Lords will allow a further appeal. While he has accepted that he hacked into US government sites, McKinnon has consistently denied causing serious damage.
According to his solicitors, although the Court of Appeal turned down McKinnon's case today, remarks made by the judges during the course of the one-day hearing, as well as the judgement, open the possibility that McKinnon could still appeal to the House of Lords. A member of McKinnon's legal team said: "There were questions about the way in which the US handled the appeal. This related to the plea bargain and the coercion applied."
The controversy centred around what was said to McKinnon when he was being offered a plea bargain by the US government. Plea bargains are common in US law but less common, and more informally applied, in the UK. A plea bargain is when the prosecution offers a reduced sentence or other incentive in return for a defendant agreeing to co-operate. In this case, the deal offered to McKinnon agreed was a reduced sentence of three years (as opposed to a possible 15 to 20) if he agreed to co-operate with US authorities. They would also let him serve the sentence in a UK prison and not in a US "super, high-security prison", as Edmund Lawson, QC, for McKinnon's defence, put it.
All parties appear to agree on this part but what was said next was the source of controversy in court. According to McKinnon and his counsel, a US member of the prosecution team then "threatened" McKinnon that if he did not agree to the bargain, they would push for the highest possible penalties and he would be "turned over to New Jersey authorities to see him fry". And, the defence further alleged, the US said if McKinnon did not agree to the deal there would be no chance of him serving his sentence in the UK near his friends and family.
McKinnon's hopes of the case being referred to the House of Lords are not high. The Extradition Act 2003 is a revised version of the original act, which was introduced in the wake of the attack on the World Trade Center and applies only to extradition to the UK from the US. No appeal against extradition has so far been successful and the UK government has no powers under that act to extradite US citizens to the UK.
Colin Barker writes for ZDNet UK
So the doors were wide open (default remote contro...
Mr Pink
If this guy was a genuine "ethical hacker" he shou...
Anonymous
I'm in IT and I disagree that NASA is more to blam...
NJ Cesar
The facts of the case are to some degree irrelevan...
Nick Azazel
Nasa hacker fights extradition to the US
Nasa hacker appeal to be heard next year
McKinnon extradition backlash underway
Nasa hacker's extradition gets Reid's rubber-stamp
Kevin Mitnick has little sympathy for Nasa hacker
UK Nasa hacker loses extradition fight
NASA hacker fears Guantanamo imprisonment
New twist in Nasa hacker hearing
To maintain the best possible relations with the tax authorities consistent with arguing vigorously (but reasonably) for the optimum result of the ...
Act Now! You have the opportunity to move into a fantastic company with potential for excellent growth and exposure in the Oil and Gas industry. As ...
Qualifications: * Demonstrable expertise in project or programme management * Leadership qualities to support global initiatives within a matrix ...
CIO50 2008
The silicon.com CIO50 2008 profiles the most influential and innovative tech chiefs in the UK across all industries and organisation size, from the biggest FTSE100 companies to high growth dot-com start ups and the public sector. The list was voted on by the UK CIO community and a panel of experts. Find out more in our latest special report.
July 10th: Just MASH Marketing: The Customer Reference Mashup
TechNet Webcast: How Microsoft Does IT: Management and Operations in Windows Server...
Mashing it up with Support: Automate, Coordinate and Collaborate with the Incident...
Ensure Virtualization is Meeting Your Needs--Read this New White Paper
Stories from the web...
Copyright ©1995-2008 CNET Networks, Inc. All rights reserved. Top of page
Peter Cochrane Peter Cochrane's Blog: Quality by design Why do picky people settle for poor design at work?
Naked CIO The Naked CIO: Service level disagreements SLAs - not worth the paper they're written on?