
By Martin Brampton
Published: Tuesday 19 October 2004
Email story to a Friend | Report Abuse
Name
Paul Wilson
Location
London
Occupation
Network Consultant
Comment
ID Cards for everyone??? Does this mean that from day 1 (or from when a child is registered (birth) or when a person reaches a certain age?? Does the government think that they will be able to spot a terrorist form an ID card. People develop different ideals at different ages, and unlike some films, we do not all think alike (thankfully). ID cards can be classed as an infringment on privacy, especially if they are used to track movemnents, or for example trends. What is the idea of ID cards, to be shown when you travel? would you be required to show your ID as you would if you were to get on a train, bus?? What DATA will be kept on an ID card, Name, Address, Birthdate, Marital status, Blood Group, National Insurance no. Healthcare no. ?? these are the things that are being bandied about, but this information, on one card!!! That will allow for Identity theft on a large scale. Codes can be broken, encryption can be stolen. There has been attempts to share data within the NHS for over 20 years now, and everything is still disjointed, to bring all this together, as the gevernment are trying to sell this, would be at least (at the current state of affairs and procedings) 40 years away, if they could agree on a platform in which to start from. Not only would the government have to agree on a set standard for this country, but they would have to adopt a standard that would be european wide, as they will have to conform to EU standards on private data transfer. Just think how much junk mail and email you get from filling in a form on an Internet site, or mail order form, or even buying something in a shop. Now times by millions, as you can be assured, that someone will sell your info to a company, who in turn will sell it to another company, who in turn will sell it to another etc etc etc. ID CARDS - NO - if it ever gets off the ground, beware, or tell a few porkies here and there.
Given:
1. the total indifference of politician...
Karen Meidl
I would have thought the Home Office would have a ...
Richard
I value the freedom in the UK of not having to pro...
Paul Smith
This is abolutely spot on. The benefits of ID card...
Anonymous
ID Cards for everyone??? Does this mean that from ...
Paul Wilson
ID's - NHS number and passport or EU id card alrea...
James Button
No, the real question is:
Is it more convenient...
Richard Sarson
So most people want a card eh? Maybe so, most peop...
Ken Hall
So most people want a card eh? maybe so, most peop...
Ken Hall
This is one of these debates where the doomsayers ...
Fred Perkins
I agree that the real issue is the database, and t...
Ian Savell
Disproving the threats...
Of course nobody can ...
Anonymous
High Cost, Low Benefit of Government Regulations:
...
Richard2
Where is the respect for democracy, human rights o...
Anonymous
They're coming at some point. Let's hope that they...
Carl Young
'Only the most sophisticated, and therefore costly...
Neil Barrett
I have my suspicions that we dont really live in a...
jonathan
Think of the cost. BAse it on how much the NHS fia...
Mikal Dunne
As a Christian and ethnic miniority person, I have...
Anonymous
Some brilliant comments here, especially by Ken Ha...
Lee Wardle
How about an alternative model to all these databa...
Anonymous
How about an alternative model to all these databa...
Anonymous
The ID card scheme is the next phase in a much lar...
Luke
Although I am not as perturbed by the intro of ID ...
Richard
It's not the card it's the datatbase and who'll be...
Adair
It's not the card it's the datatbase and who'll be...
Adair
Nectar cards are voluntary. Like the majority of U...
Chris Allonby
Whatever happened to "terrorists must never dictat...
Anonymous
I know that nectar cards are voluntarily, but my p...
Richard
Everything the govt currently holds, and everythin...
Tanya Gibbs
COST EFFECTIVENESS
Sure let's have biometric ID...
Drew Edgar
ID cards will inevitably change the relationship b...
Anonymous
Agenda Setters 2009
Welcome to the ninth annual Agenda Setters poll – silicon.com's list of the top 50 most influential individuals in the technology and IT industries, from techies and CIOs to entrepreneurs and business leaders. Find out more in our latest special report.
Data Protection Strategies: Deduplication for More Efficient Backups
Dell PowerVault DL2100 Powered by CommVault - Spec Sheet
True Convergence Demands a Communication Service Provider that Embraces a Customer-Centric...
Learn how Performance Metrics for Telcomm Expense Management Drive new ROIs and SLAs
Copyright © 2008 CBS Interactive Limited. All rights reserved. Top of page
The Round-Up The Weekly Round-Up: 03.12.09 'Ere guv, you'll never guess who I had in the back of my cab the other day…'
Stuart Roberts Shared services - how to get it right in your business Recession boosts uptake