To print: Click here or Select File and then Print from your browser's menu

This story was printed from silicon.com, located at http://www.silicon.com/

Story URL: http://management.silicon.com/government/0,39024677,39181363,00.htm

Microsoft's OOXML wins 'standard' stamp
Hefty blow to rivals…

By Reuters

Published: Wednesday 02 April 2008

Microsoft has won the battle to have a key document format adopted as a global standard, improving its chances of winning government contracts and dealing a blow to supporters of a rival format.

The OpenDoc Society - which had argued Microsoft's Office Open XML (OOXML) format was unripe for ratification by the International Organization for Standardization (ISO) - published the results showing Microsoft's win on its website.

Latest photo stories from silicon.com

1. Photos: The Colossus WWII codebreaking machine

2. Photos: US military puts 'bat' spies in the sky…

3. Photos: Conquering the arctic wilderness

4. Photos: Red Bull Racing's F1 factory

5. Photos: Viruses and Trojans come to life

6. Photos: RFID bumblebees create a buzz

7. Photos: When art meets tech - Nokia phone Morphs into view

8. Photos: Lunar mobile phones preparing to soar

9. Photos: Nokia Navigator maps out the route on foot

10. Photos: Google Android comes out to play

Microsoft welcomed the decision, which was leaked yesterday ahead of an official ISO statement expected today, saying it created a "level playing field" for OOXML to compete with other standards.

Supporters of rival Open Document Format (ODF), which is already an ISO standard and widely used, said multiple formats defeated the purpose of having standards and the result would help Microsoft tighten its grip on computer users.

Tom Robertson, Microsoft's head of interoperability and standards, said: "Open XML joins the ranks of PDF, HTML and ODF among the ranks of document formats. I think it makes it easier for governments to offer users choice."

He added in a phone interview: "The control over the specification now moves into the hands of the global community. This is going to be one of the most, if not the most important document format around the world for years to come."

James Love, director of Knowledge Economy International, which campaigns for fairer access to knowledge, said: "We are disappointed."

He said: "Microsoft's control over document formats has destroyed competition on the desktop, and the fight over OOXML is really a fight over the future of competition and innovation."

Microsoft, shepherded through a fast-track ISO approval process by European standards organisation Ecma, lost a first ISO vote in September. Under the process, a second vote was allowed after a so-called ballot resolution meeting last month.

In the second voting period that closed on 29 March, Microsoft won the approval of 86 per cent of voting national bodies and 75 per cent of those known as P-members. A two-thirds majority of the P-members was required.

Among those voting in favour of OOXML were Germany, Japan, the UK and the US, according to the OpenDoc Society list. Opponents included China, India and Russia.

The process tested ISO to its limits as national bodies waded through the 6,000 pages of code that define OOXML, then dealt with more than a thousand points of order at the ballot resolution meeting, which was designed to help reach consensus.

ODF has just 860 pages of code, one of the reasons many experts argue that translation between the two is too incomplete to allow true interoperability - a concept Microsoft has recently publicly embraced.

Michiel Leenaars, who is on the OpenDoc Society board and chaired the Dutch committee in the first stage of the ISO process, said OOXML was not ready to be an international standard and that the 15-month ISO process had been too fast.

In a phone interview he said: "It was mission impossible. The process wasn't meant for this type of thing."